No place for set-and-forget asset allocation

Glenn Freeman  |  04/10/2016Text size  Decrease  Increase  |  

Glenn Freeman: I'm Glenn Freeman for Morningstar and I'm joined today by Shane Oliver, Chief Economist and Head of Investment Strategy for AMP Capital.

Shane, thanks for joining us.

Dr. Shane Oliver: My pleasure. Glad to be here.

Freeman: Shane, what's your assessment of Australian-listed companies' performance given that fiscal 2016 has now ended?

Oliver: Overall, I thought the reporting season was okay. I mean, it wasn't going to be a great year because, don't forget, resources companies have been hit by a massive blow from the fall in commodity prices.

So that really dragged down the resources part of the market and of course, that flowed on to the rest of the market. So, overall, profits were down about 8 per cent. But just bear in mind, there was a 47 per cent-odd slump in resources sector profit, so that's what really dragged things down.

But if you sort of look in the details, they weren't too bad. You can see the median company actually saw a profit growth of around 4 or 5 per cent. 62 per cent of companies actually saw their profits rise from a year ago.

And…over 50 per cent of companies, when they reported their results, actually saw their share price outperform the market on the day of release. In other words, the market took the results reasonably well.

And I think the other thing is that this has sort of set a base for a bounce back in profits as we go through the current financial year.

So, I think that's the really important thing from this. There wasn't a lot of disappointment. And if anything, there was a slight upgrade to earnings, particularly for resources stocks and as they go from being a big negative to being a positive that should drag overall profit growth of listed companies over the next 12 months up to around 8 per cent after the falls of the last year.

Freeman: And were any of these sector results particularly surprising for you?

Oliver: There were a couple of sector results that did surprise me. The resources perhaps were one of them. We had been used to resources companies surprising on the downside, but you saw a few key companies there actually surprise on the upside and that's why you saw upgrades to earnings expectation for the resources sector.

BHP, Rio, Fortescue even, results there I thought were a lot better than feed and probably better than I was expecting.

The other area of surprise was what's often called discretionary retail. These are retail companies focused on discretionary spending items as opposed to consumer staples like supermarkets.

And the discretionary retailer saw pretty good results and a part of that was driven by a great company JB Hi-Fi doing well, continuing to do well, but part of it generally, I think, was consumer spending coming back.

We have seen reasonable growth in consumer spending over the last 12 months, albeit still a very competitive environment, lots of weakness in terms of pricing power. But in terms of volumes, those seem to be coming through and that's helping retailers.

Freeman: Now, Shane, especially in the SMSF sector, we hear a lot about an over-allocation to Australian shares. Is this something that you see as a problem?

Oliver: Well, there are positives and minuses with an allocation to Australian shares. I think the reality is that Australian shares do provide a good cash flow and you get the franking credits.

So, you're always going to buy. So, if you've got your investment portfolio and you're an Australian-based investor and you get access to those franking credits, you're going to have a bias towards Australian shares.

The trouble is I think that some SMSF investors do attack a little too far and you end up with a situation of having too many of your eggs in just one basket. And if we go through a period like the last five or six years where Australian shares underperformed, say, global shares then that can actually be a negative for your wealth. Even though you get an income flow, you're not getting the capital growth that global shares offer you.

So, I think, yeah, there is a bit of a problem there, that I wouldn't go the full hog and say, well, I only have 1 per cent or 2 per cent in Australian shares, like if you're a Martian, that's probably all you'd have in Australian shares.

So, I still have a decent bias towards Australian shares, but look, I think it would make sense for investors to have a bit more internationally given the sectoral exposure you get internationally, particularly IT stocks, consumer stocks and so on that you don't have in Australian, the growth potential globally and also the diversification benefits.

You often find that when Australian shares were underperforming global shares were doing better and that helps protect your portfolio. And likewise, when you go global depending on how you do it, you get exposure to foreign currency. And just as the Aussie dollar is going down over the last few years, foreign currency is going up in value and that also helps your portfolio.

Freeman: Now, just further to that last question. Do you believe that Australian SMSF investors are active enough in their asset allocation approaches?

Oliver: So, on one hand, you can say that the old set-and-forget approach that we had through the '80s and the '90s where you could just put some money down as an investment and most things did pretty well through that period, apart from occasional setbacks, because we saw a very favourable environment economically and also financially. The tide was rising. All boats were being pulled up. You didn't have to put a lot of effort into trying to get the cycle right.

Now, we're going through an environment which is a lot more constrained, a lot more volatile and therefore, there is a case to employ a more active approach to asset allocation. The problem is for individual investors, it's very hard to get that right because you're bombarded with information.

There's multiples of information flowing at these days that wasn't around in the '80s or in the '90s and that can be very confusing and can throw investors off.

So, I think they have a choice here. Either you adopt the set-and-forget approach, but you've got to bear in mind you're going to hit more volatility and lower returns than you got in the past; or you go down the path of saying 'I'm going to do this myself but I'm going to put the effort in'.

'I am going to make sure I get the right information flows and I get a process to help me through that,' and you've got to be aware here, you do have to put a lot effort in, or alternatively, you invest in vehicles that might help you do that, funds which do a bit of asset allocation as part of that process.

Freeman: And just lastly, you've spoken about the likelihood of a residential property slowdown in our capital cities. Should SMSF trustees rebalance their portfolios away from direct property?

Oliver: I think now is not the time to be heavily investing in or exposed to residential property, but it depends on which city you're in. I think the reality is, in Sydney and Melbourne we're seeing fantastic gains over the last four years, 40 per cent, 50 per cent gains in Sydney, a little bit less in Melbourne.

So that's going to come to an end. The cycle doesn't keep going up forever. Sooner or later you're going to get a bit of a downswing. And you're not getting a lot of rental growth through. Rental yields on average are pushing down below 3%. So, that's not a positive either.

And in the meantime, you've got this massive construction cycle. You look over the horizon in Sydney and Melbourne and to a lesser degree, Brisbane and Perth, you see cranes all over the place and that's going to put downwards pressure on apartment prices over the next few years.

So, I'd be a bit cautious about the residential property markets, particularly in Sydney and Melbourne. I'd focus more if I was intent on having an investment property in those cities, I'd focus on areas where you don't have lots of cranes, so you don't have a lot of supply really.

But you've got to really do your homework now. It's not as easy as it was, say, four years ago. And I'd probably be looking – if I was going to allocate more money, I've been looking at cities which have been underperforming in recent years.

I'd prefer Brisbane over Sydney, for example, because Brisbane has been lagging. At some point in time, you might say, well, let's allocate some money to Perth or Darwin which have been seeing price falls. So, value is starting to emerge there. I think it's got a little bit further to go though, so I won't rush in right now, but over the next couple of years, worth looking at.

But I think the property asset class which is probably a better bet at the moment is commercial property.

Commercial property has been doing well, but it's been lagging what you've been seeing in, say, Sydney and Melbourne and it doesn't have the potential oversupply problems.

And by commercial I mean office, retail, industrial sort of properties. So, I think if I was an SMSF investor, I'd be focusing on commercial and I'd be focusing on cities which haven't had the huge gains and where there isn't a big supply if you are going down the residential property path.

Freeman: Shane, thanks very much for your time.

Oliver: It's been my pleasure. Great to be here.

Freeman: I'm Glenn Freeman for Morningstar. Thanks for watching.

Video Archive...

Earnings season FY17 mixed bag so far
18/08/2017  Aside from a few high-profile earnings guidance misses, large-cap stocks are doing okay as FY17 reporting season passes halfway, says AMP chief economist Shane Oliver.
Self-managed super is not Do-it-yourself
03/07/2017  There are a few common pitfalls in running a self-managed super fund that mean trustees shouldn't go it alone entirely, says BT Financial Group's head of financial literacy, Bryan Ashenden.
How to guard against retirement threats
16/06/2017  As retirement approaches, even the best-laid plans can go awry, as Tim Steffen tells Christine Benz, Morningstar US.
No place for set-and-forget asset allocation
04/10/2016  A 2016 company reporting season overview and explanation of why dynamic asset allocation is so important, from Dr Shane Oliver, chief economist and director of investment strategy, AMP Capital.
Helping SMSF trustees negotiate super complexities
19/08/2016  Peter Hogan, head of technical at the SMSF Association, shares his insights on the changing super environment and how it will affect SMSF trustees.
Safe withdrawal rates for retirees
02/02/2016  Morningstar's Anthony Serhan explains why retirees in Australia should use lower initial safe withdrawal rates than those suggested in prior research.
Pitfalls of investing for retirement
30/09/2015  Bad behaviour before and in retirement can take a major hit to your savings. We outline the pitfalls to avoid if you want to maximise your pension pot.
4 retiree to-dos in a turbulent market
02/09/2015  Despite the market swings, retirees can control stuff like checking cash reserves and spending levels.
3 key risks for retirees
24/06/2015  Accurium SMSF technical services manager Melanie Dunn discusses three factors trustees should be aware of as they move from the accumulation to the retirement phase.
Top global tech opportunities
30/04/2015  Australia's foremost global investor Kerr Neilson identifies global drivers and those undervalued companies that are positioned for strong growth.
Key takeaways from the Murray inquiry, SuperStream
23/04/2015  The SMSF Association's Graeme Colley discusses important points from both the Murray inquiry and the SuperStream initiative, while also giving trustees tips on how to avoid unwanted "gardening leave".
Revisiting the sole purpose test
19/03/2015  It’s important that trustees are reminded about their obligations under the sole purpose test – a key requirement in SMSF compliance.
Trustees under the spotlight
--  SMSF Association’s Andrea Slattery talks about the growing professionalism of the industry and what it means for trustees.
Taxing times for trustees?
05/03/2015  The government may have moved to address the tax concessions into super but trustees face a number of potential taxing issues.
Key issues for SMSFs
02/02/2015  A government inquiry and tax concessions are among the key issues confronting trustees.
Top SMSF tips for 2015
21/01/2015  Keeping up-to-date on legislative changes, avoiding excess contributions and ensuring sufficient cash flow is in place are just some of the simple things trustees can do to get a better handle on their SMSF.
7 reasons why SMSFs outperform
22/07/2014  The key advantages to running a self-managed superannuation funds have also translated into strong performance.
What the advice reforms mean for SMSFs
09/07/2014  SPAA’s Graeme Colley outlines what SMSF trustees need to do to ensure the advice they are getting complies with the government’s proposed reforms.
A tax date with your SMSF
02/06/2014  SPAA's Graeme Colley outlines a number of important dates for tax payers as the 30 June deadline looms.
Keeping your SMSF simple
21/05/2014  Oasis Wealth's Barbara Smith offers some thoughts on the property market and some simple advice on how not to get into trouble with the ATO.
Getting SMSF ready for SuperStream
03/04/2014  SMSF members who accept employer contributions will need to prepare for the government’s new measure called SuperStream.
Is your SMSF audit ready?
27/03/2014  SMSF trustees face new audit requirements from the Australian Taxation Office
Key rulings for SMSFs
20/03/2014  AMP's Peter Burgess outlines key legislative considerations for trustees
Do trustees know best?
17/03/2014  --
Getting ready for contribution cap rises
13/03/2014  The indexation of the contribution caps will give people the opportunity to put more into superannuation.
3 key legislative changes for SMSF trustees
07/02/2014  Trustees need to grapple with a number of legislative changes made by the ATO.
5 new year resolutions
23/01/2014  Westpac's David Simon outlines five key new year resolutions that will maximise portfolio performance.
Getting value from your property portfolio
21/01/2014  Property expert Margaret Lomas outlines effective strategies for maximising a property portfolio and managing these assets in retirement.
What can SMSF trustees expect in 2014?
17/12/2013  A new government inquiry into financial services will be among the key issues trustees will have to grapple with in 2014.
Do SMSFs need a minimum balance?
30/10/2013  Should minimum balances be set for SMSFs in order for them to be run effectively?
Understanding new SMSF guidelines
20/09/2013  BT Financial Group’s Bryan Ashenden explains the proposed guidelines for advisers operating in the SMSF market and the implications for trustees.
What the Coalition means for super
13/09/2013  The new government will cut back on concessions for low-income earners and will most likely re-think excess contributions for SMSFs.
Key changes to super caps
25/07/2013  The latest changes to concessional superannuation caps may mean a change of strategy for trustees.
What the budget means for SMSFs
15/05/2013  While there were little in surprises in this week’s budget, there are a number of issues trustees still need to consider.
What to do with falling super contribution caps
--  With the government limiting how much you can contribute to super, a number of other wealth creation strategies are available.
SMSFs - the pros and cons
26/03/2012  Westpac’s David Simon outlines the benefits of SMSFS as well as the traps to avoid.
Cooper, super and SMSFs
--  Understanding the Cooper review's proposed changes to our super and SMSFs.
The changing role of fixed interest
21/09/2010  An inevitable rise in global bond yields may expose investors to negative returns - unless they prepare now.
Super's good, bad and the ugly
23/09/2010  We're not doing ourselves any favours by clinging to a lump-sum mentality when it comes to super.
Planning your DIY super in 2012
23/01/2012  Having the right plan is critical if trustees are to navigate the big changes to concessional caps this year.
Time to get out of cash?
01/09/2011  SMSFs have boosted their cash allocations but is it time to diversify into other asset classes?
All you need to know about SMSFs
31/03/2011  Grant Abbott discusses what attendees can expect at the upcoming Morningstar SMSF Trustee Strategy Day.
Death's effect on SMSF borrowings
06/10/2010  The death of an SMSF member has significant consequences when a gearing strategy is in place.
Lump sums have merit too
28/09/2010  Considering an income stream in retirement? Don't ignore lump sums.
Property acquisitions using gearing
22/09/2010  A look at some of the finer points about using limited recourse loans to purchase property within super funds.
5 ways SMSFs may become non-complying
13/09/2010  Becoming non-complying is one of the worst things that can happen to your fund. So avoid it.
Extra pay needs extra planning
31/05/2010  Extra pay, windfalls and bonuses are great but good planning can make it better.
Art for SMSFs' sake
31/08/2010  Artwork and collectables back on the table for SMSF investors.
Emerging trends in SMSFs
04/08/2010  SPAA chair Sharyn Long shares her knowledge of what SMSFs are up to at the moment.
Tax tips for SMSFs in FY10/11
19/07/2010  SPAA chair Sharyn Long shares her knowledge of what SMSFs are up to at the moment.
Getting SMSF taxes ready
--  We’ve put a line under FY09/10 but how do we best prepare our taxes for the year.
Putting that extra into super
--  Andrew Proebstl, chief executive of legalsuper tells us how the fund encouraged record voluntary contributions from members
Super no shelter for fraud
--  --
Do SMSFs seek advice?
--  SMSF members like control but do they eschew advice?
Super changes and SMSFs
--  Super has been tinkered with yet again but what are the implications for SMSFs?
Beware capital gains tax on SMSF rollovers
--  Certain activities in running a self managed super fund can trigger capital gains tax liabilities.
Avoid horrific penalties
--  The ATO is focused on excess contributions in SMSFs.
Insurance gets built-in for longer living
--  Lifetime income guarantee funds make sure your money won’t run out.
ETFs for easy diversification: pioneer
--  ETF pioneer Jim Ross of State Street Global Advisers explains why these products are gaining popularity.
Hefty tax for exceeding caps
--  What to do if you exceed the superannuation contribution caps.
Actuaries measure risks of ageing
--  The actuaries’ role in determining risks and helping governments formulate economic policy.
Penalties for your SMSF's poor report
--  SPAA chair Sharyn Long talks about the auditor contravention report and how SMSF trustees can best deal with them.
Ensuring your auditor is qualified
--  SPAA accredited auditors have now become approved auditors under the SIS Act.
Making the nest egg last the distance
--  --
Keep your super in the family
--  Is your SMSF for the whole family? Grant Abbott discusses if you should have insurance or other products included.
Penalties for your SMSF’s poor report
--  SPAA chair Sharyn Long talks about the auditor contravention report and how SMSF trustees can best deal with them.
New TPD insurance regulations
--  --
SMSF Reserves
--  --
Will your SMSF pass these tests?
--  How Australian is your SMSF? Dire consequences await those funds that fail to meet requirements.
SMSFs and gearing
--  SMSF expert Grant Abbott talks to Darin Tyson-Chan some of the basic facts surrounding the use of borrowing in an SMSF.
Binding death benefit nominations
--  SMSF Strategies principal Grant Abbott discusses the merits of having a binding death benefit nomination within an SMSF with Darin Tyson-Chan.
The SMSF in-house asset rule
--  Darin Tyson-Chan speaks to SMSF Strategies principal Grant Abbott about the amended in-house assets rule for SMSFs
Divorce and your SMSF - what you need to know
--  Breaking up is hard to do, especially without a contingency plan in your SMSF for divorce.
Trustee responsibility (pt 1)
--  Trustees often trip over the law with SMSFs, lawyer Peter Townsend warns in the first of this two-part interview.
Trustee responsibility (pt 2)
--  The second part of this SMSF discussion provides tips for trustees
Not too late for super tweaks
--  Tax time is over but tax planning around super need not be. Clearview's Dante De Gori explains
Maximum earnings and super contributions
--  Salary sacrificing? Understanding the 10 per cent maximum earnings rule is a must.
Could ETFs benefit your super?
--  What you need to know about Exchange Traded Funds and retirement savings
SMSFs and gearing
--  Administrative considerations with Andrew Biviano and Darin Tyson-Chan
Trustee Education
--  Liz Westover gives her recommended changes to superannuation trustee skill and knowledge.